For this wine and cheese pairing, a group of friends and I tried three different wines and four different cheeses. We enjoyed the wine and cheese with some bread and olive oil in between pairings.
Cheeses (Before Pairing):
Fontina
This cheese was light and buttery. It was my favorite out of the four cheeses. According to Wine Folly, delicate, buttery cheeses pair great with sparkling, white, and dessert wines.
Brie
Similar to the Fontina, this cheese was soft and light. I also enjoyed this cheese very much. Since Brie is also a delicate, buttery cheese, it should also pair great with sparking, white, and dessert wines.
I did not find the Sharp Cheddar as appealing as the first two cheeses, but it was still quite tasty alone. This cheese was sharp and strong on my tounge. Wine Folly has cheddar under the fruity, umami cheeses, which pair great with medium-bodied and full-bodied red wines.
Even though I have not liked Blue Cheese in the past, I decided to give it another taste. Unfortunately, I though the taste was way to strong and, honestly, gross. As a pungent Blue Cheese, Wine Folly suggests pairing this cheese with aromatic white wine and dessert wine, and said to stay away from light- and full-bodied white for red wines. I tried the blue cheese with a few of the wines, but did not find any of the tastes appealing. There will be no further notes on this cheese.
Wines:
Bell'Agio Chianti (2022)
Grape Variety: Sangiovese, Canaiolo
Country & Region: Italy, Tuscany, Chianti
Price: $16
Vintage: 2022
Critic Review: Has a fresh and floral aroma with hints of ripe berries and plums and just a touch of oak. Bursting with fresh raspberries, the firm tannins and good balancing acidity round out this wine that has a lot of flavor in it. There is some cuisine that pairs well with this delicious wine.
My Tasting Experience:
Before Pairing:
This wine had a sweet, but strong aroma. The taste alone was more earthy and had a tannic aftertaste. Athough sweet, the dryness filled my mouth. Overall, I enjoyed this wine.
After Pairing:
The Fontina cheese paired the best with this wine! The flavor of the wine seemed to spread across the tounge after eating this cheese. The flavor was definitely enhanced with this pairing. While the Sharp Cheddar tasted good with the wine, this cheese had an overpowering aftertaste. Finally, the Brie was a mad match for the Chianti. The two flavors just did not mix well.
Barefoot Merlot
Grape Variety: Merlot
Country & Region: United States, California
Price: $12
Vintage: NV
Critic Review: Luscious wine with alluring flavors of boysenberry and split cherries followed by hints of silky chocolate for a decadent finish.
My Tasting Experience:
Before Pairing:
When first smelling the aromas of this wine, a stronger grape smell was present. I could not pick out any other smell, since this grape was so overpowering. When tasting, the Merlot was sweet and not dry. I picked out a delicious plum/jam taste which could be attributed to the boyseberry and split cherries.
After Pairing:
I thouroughly enjoyed the Sharp Cheddar with this wine. It made the flavors very smooth in the mouth. The Fontina also had a smooth taste, but the aftertaste was strong, overpowering the wine. The wine seemed to greatly affect the taste of the Brie. The pairing was sour and not appetizing.
Maipe Malbec
Grape Variety: Malbec
Country & Region: Argentina, Maipu Valley
Price: $10
Vintage: 2019?
Critic Review: This Mallbec has a deep purple color with violet tints, complex plum, fig, strawberry, spices, and floral aromas; rounded and velvety tanins, excellent length with a distiguished character.
My Tasting Experience:
Before Pairing:
This Malbec had strong grape aromas mixed with another smell I could not identify, although pleasant. The taste was overall delicious! This wine was definitely more complex and fuller-bodied.
After Pairing:
Unfortuately, I did not find a cheese that I thought paired well with this wine. The Fontina did not cause an unpleasant taste, but I did not feel as if this cheese was meant to be paired with this wine. The Sharp Cheddar also did not mix well, overpowering the wine. When tasting the Brie, the wine caused the cheese to be too milky and pulled out the moldy, poor tasting parts of the cheese.
My friend recently bought a decanter, so we decided to let the Malbec decant for a few hours. I am unsure how this affected the taste, since we did not taste the wine beforehand. However, I could see the oxygen mixing with the wine as we swirled the vessel, and I feel the aromas became more powerful. We will be using the dacanter for future tastings as well!
Now, off to uncork my next adventure!
RG